Loading blog content, please wait...
Two Rentals, Same Price, and One Makes You More Money Put two Franklin rentals side by side at the same purchase price and you'd expect them to perform ...
Put two Franklin rentals side by side at the same purchase price and you'd expect them to perform about the same. They almost never do. One will hand you steadier income for years, and the other will quietly eat into your returns through vacancy, turnover, and repairs you didn't budget for.
The difference isn't in the listing price. It's in a handful of details that don't show up on the MLS sheet, and knowing which ones matter is what separates a rental that works from one that just sits there looking fine.
Two three-bedroom homes in Franklin might both be listed at $525,000. Same square footage, same year built, similar photos. On paper they're twins.
But one is in a pocket near Westhaven where tenants renew year after year because they want their kids in that school zone. The other is on a busier stretch closer to Cool Springs where renters cycle through faster, drawn by the commute but not tied down by much else. Same price, very different turnover.
Turnover is where returns leak. Every time a tenant leaves, you're looking at a few weeks of vacancy, cleaning, minor repairs, and the cost of finding someone new. A home that keeps good tenants for three years quietly outperforms an identical one that turns over annually, even if the rent is a hair lower.
It's tempting to compare two rentals by the rent they command. The one asking $2,900 a month looks better than the one at $2,650. But rent is the top line, and the top line lies.
What you keep depends on what you spend to get there. A slightly higher rent on a home with an aging HVAC, an older roof, and a yard that needs regular attention can net you less than a lower rent on a home where the big systems were replaced five years ago.
The honest comparison is what lands in your account after the mortgage, taxes, insurance, management, and a realistic maintenance reserve. Run both properties through that math and the "cheaper" rent often wins.
Roof, HVAC, water heater, and the age of the plumbing and electrical. These four things decide whether your first three years are calm or expensive.
Two homes at the same price can be a decade apart on these systems even if they were built the same year. One owner replaced the roof and both HVAC units recently. The other kept things running but is due for all of it soon.
That gap can be $20,000 or more in near-term spending, and it never appears in the sale price.
Ask for the age of every major system before you compare returns. If a seller can't tell you, that's information too, and you should budget as if replacement is coming sooner than you'd like.
Franklin isn't one rental market. It's several, and each one attracts a different kind of tenant with different expectations and different staying power.
A home near downtown Franklin and the historic square draws people who love walking to Main Street and tend to value where they live enough to stay. A newer build out toward Berry Farms attracts families settling in for the school years. A place closer to the interstate leans toward tenants optimizing for commute, who move when the commute changes.
None of these is wrong. But they produce different vacancy patterns, and if you're comparing two rentals only on price, you're ignoring the single biggest driver of long-term income.
A home that's genuinely ready to lease and a home that needs a few weeks of work look nearly identical in listing photos. On price they can be identical too.
The difference is time. Every week you spend painting, replacing flooring, or updating a dated kitchen is a week without rent, plus the cost of the work itself. A rental you can list the week you close starts paying immediately.
One that needs a month of prep costs you that month twice, once in expense and once in lost rent.
This isn't a reason to avoid a property that needs work. It's a reason to fold that work into your comparison honestly, so you're weighing true cost against true cost.
When a client brings us two Franklin rentals at the same price, we don't start with the price at all. We start with a projected annual net for each, built from real rent comps in that specific neighborhood, the actual age of the systems, a maintenance reserve that reflects the home's condition, and an honest read on how long tenants tend to stay in that area.
At Redbird Real Estate, that side-by-side often flips the obvious choice. The property that looked better on price frequently comes in second once you account for turnover and near-term repairs, and the one that looked ordinary turns out to be the steadier earner.
The goal is simple: you should be choosing between two projected returns, not two purchase prices. Once you're looking at the right numbers, the better rental usually makes itself obvious.
Before you decide between two Franklin rentals, get the age of the roof, HVAC, water heater, and major systems for both. Pull rent comps specific to each neighborhood, not a citywide average. Estimate a real maintenance reserve based on condition, and factor in how much prep each home needs before it can be listed.
Then compare the projected net, not the price and not the rent. Two rentals at the same cost can be thousands of dollars apart in what they actually pay you every year, and the one that wins is rarely the one that looked cheaper or asked for more rent.
That's the whole exercise. Same price in, very different money out, and the difference is entirely in the details you check before you buy.