Loading blog content, please wait...
You Just Inherited a House and You Don't Want to Be a Landlord A house shows up in your life during one of the hardest stretches a person goes through. ...
A house shows up in your life during one of the hardest stretches a person goes through. Nobody picks the timing. And somewhere between the funeral and the paperwork, you realize you now own a three-bedroom on the other side of Franklin, or two counties away, and everyone keeps telling you to "just rent it out."
You don't have to. Being a landlord is one option among several, and for a lot of people it's the wrong fit. Here's how to think through what you actually want to do with it.
The house isn't going anywhere, and neither is the decision. The pressure you feel usually comes from other people, not from the property itself.
What does need attention early is practical and small. Keep the insurance active (a vacant-home policy if nobody's living there), make sure the utilities stay on through the fall so pipes don't sit cold, and get the locks changed. Those steps buy you months of breathing room.
Once the estate side is settled and the title is clear, you can make a real decision instead of a rushed one.
A rental in Franklin can be a genuinely good asset. Demand around here is steady, and a well-kept home near good schools or an easy commute to Cool Springs holds its value and rents without much drama.
The catch is that renting isn't passive. It's a small business with tenants, maintenance calls, a lease you have to actually enforce, and a tax picture that changes the day you collect your first rent check. If the house is 200 miles away or you already have a full plate, that's a lot to take on by yourself.
This is where a lot of inherited-home owners land somewhere in the middle: they like the idea of keeping the property but have zero interest in being the person who gets the 10 p.m. water-heater call.
Full-service property management exists for exactly this situation. Someone else handles the leasing, screens tenants, collects rent, coordinates repairs, and deals with the parts of the job you'd rather not touch. You stay the owner and get the monthly deposit and the long-term appreciation.
This is the piece people don't always realize is available. You can hold a Franklin rental as an investment and never personally meet a tenant. At Redbird Real Estate we do this for owners who are out of state, busy, or simply uninterested in the day-to-day, and it's one of the most common reasons an inherited house stays in the family instead of getting sold in a hurry.
The honest tradeoff is the management fee, usually a percentage of rent. For most owners who'd otherwise lose nights and weekends to the property, that fee is the whole point.
Some houses should be sold, and there's nothing sentimental or financial lost in saying so. If the home needs significant work, if splitting the money cleanly among heirs is the priority, or if you simply don't want a rental at all, selling is often the clearest path.
Franklin's market gives you decent options here. A dated but structurally sound home in a neighborhood buyers want can sell as-is to someone looking to renovate, so you're not forced to pour money into updates for a house you're leaving anyway.
One thing worth knowing: inherited property usually gets what's called a stepped-up basis, meaning the home's value resets to roughly what it was worth at the time you inherited it. That can meaningfully change the tax math on a sale. Talk to a tax professional about your specific situation before you assume you'll owe a big capital gains bill.
Within a few weeks of the house transferring, you'll start getting letters and calls from people who want to buy it quick for cash. Some are legitimate. Many are hoping you're overwhelmed enough to take a number well below what the house is worth.
A fast cash close is convenient, and convenience has value. Just get an honest sense of the home's actual market value first so you know what you're trading away for speed. A quick walkthrough with an agent who knows Franklin pricing costs you nothing and keeps you from leaving real money on the table.
If after that you still want the fast, clean exit, at least you're choosing it with open eyes.
Start with one plain question: do you want this house to be part of your financial life for the next several years, or do you want to close the chapter?
If you want to keep it and the numbers work, management lets you own without the labor. If you want it gone, a standard sale usually nets more than a cash buyer, and the stepped-up basis often makes the tax hit smaller than people fear. If the house needs more work than you want to fund, selling as-is to a renovator is a middle road that still gets you fair market exposure.
There's no single right answer here, and the best one depends on the house, your distance from it, and what you want your fall and winter to look like. What helps most is talking it through with someone who can price the home, estimate what it'd rent for, and lay the two paths side by side with real Franklin numbers instead of guesses.
Then you decide. On your timeline, not the mailbox's.